Repair or Replace: How to Decide on Aging Commercial Equipment.
Every piece of commercial equipment eventually crosses a line where fixing it stops making financial sense. Here's the framework we use with facility managers to figure out where that line actually is.
Gary Raulino5 min readFacility Maintenance

A rooftop unit dies in the middle of a heat wave and someone has to make a call in about ten minutes: fix it or replace it. That's a bad time to figure out your decision criteria. It's better to have the framework already worked out before the equipment forces the question.
Start with age against expected service life
Most commercial HVAC equipment is built for 15 to 20 years of service, commercial water heaters closer to 10 to 15, and kitchen equipment varies widely by type and use intensity. If a unit is past 70% of its expected life and needs a repair that costs more than a fraction of replacement cost, that's usually the point where replacement wins.
Look at the repair history, not just this repair
A single failure is a data point. Three failures in eighteen months on the same unit is a trend, and it means the unit is entering the failure curve where components keep going one after another. At that stage, each individual repair might look reasonable in isolation, but the running total tells a different story than any single invoice.
Factor in what the repair actually buys you
Some repairs restore a unit to full function for years. Others are a stopgap that buys a few months before the next failure, often in a related component. Ask the contractor doing the repair what else on the unit is near end of life. A compressor replacement on a unit with a rusted-through heat exchanger isn't solving the underlying problem, it's postponing the same decision.
Don't ignore efficiency losses
An aging unit running at reduced efficiency has a real ongoing cost even when it's technically working. A 15-year-old rooftop unit can use noticeably more energy than a current model doing the same job, and that gap shows up on every utility bill for as long as the old unit stays in service. Sometimes that operating cost difference alone justifies replacement even without a breakdown forcing the issue.
The 50% rule, with judgment attached
A common industry rule of thumb: if a repair costs more than 50% of replacement cost, replace. It's a reasonable starting point, but it shouldn't be the whole decision. A ten-year-old unit at 40% of replacement cost with no other issues is a clear repair. A fifteen-year-old unit at 40% of replacement cost with a rising repair history is a different conversation.
The goal isn't to hit an arbitrary threshold. It's to stop making decisions equipment failure at a time and start making them on a planned schedule, where you control the timing instead of the equipment controlling it for you.
Written by
Gary Raulino.
Gary Raulino is a highly accomplished leader with over 20 years of experience in the facility management industry.


