Repair or Replace: How to Decide on Aging Commercial Equipment.

Every piece of commercial equipment eventually crosses a line where fixing it stops making financial sense. Here's the framework we use with facility managers to figure out where that line actually is.

Gary Raulino5 min readFacility Maintenance

A rooftop unit dies in the middle of a heat wave and someone has to make a call in about ten minutes: fix it or replace it. That's a bad time to figure out your decision criteria. It's better to have the framework already worked out before the equipment forces the question.

Start with age against expected service life

Most commercial HVAC equipment is built for 15 to 20 years of service, commercial water heaters closer to 10 to 15, and kitchen equipment varies widely by type and use intensity. If a unit is past 70% of its expected life and needs a repair that costs more than a fraction of replacement cost, that's usually the point where replacement wins.

Look at the repair history, not just this repair

A single failure is a data point. Three failures in eighteen months on the same unit is a trend, and it means the unit is entering the failure curve where components keep going one after another. At that stage, each individual repair might look reasonable in isolation, but the running total tells a different story than any single invoice.

Factor in what the repair actually buys you

Some repairs restore a unit to full function for years. Others are a stopgap that buys a few months before the next failure, often in a related component. Ask the contractor doing the repair what else on the unit is near end of life. A compressor replacement on a unit with a rusted-through heat exchanger isn't solving the underlying problem, it's postponing the same decision.

Don't ignore efficiency losses

An aging unit running at reduced efficiency has a real ongoing cost even when it's technically working. A 15-year-old rooftop unit can use noticeably more energy than a current model doing the same job, and that gap shows up on every utility bill for as long as the old unit stays in service. Sometimes that operating cost difference alone justifies replacement even without a breakdown forcing the issue.

The 50% rule, with judgment attached

A common industry rule of thumb: if a repair costs more than 50% of replacement cost, replace. It's a reasonable starting point, but it shouldn't be the whole decision. A ten-year-old unit at 40% of replacement cost with no other issues is a clear repair. A fifteen-year-old unit at 40% of replacement cost with a rising repair history is a different conversation.

The goal isn't to hit an arbitrary threshold. It's to stop making decisions equipment failure at a time and start making them on a planned schedule, where you control the timing instead of the equipment controlling it for you.

Written by

Gary Raulino.

Gary Raulino is a highly accomplished leader with over 20 years of experience in the facility management industry.

Add a comment

This will be publicly visible.

Your email address will not be published.

Your comment will be reviewed by an admin before it is published.

You may also like

  • Preventive Maintenance Gary Raulino

    Why Preventive Maintenance Costs Less Than the Emergency Call

    A broken rooftop unit in July or a burst pipe in January always costs more than the inspection that would have caught it. Here's how a preventive maintenance plan changes the math for facility managers.

    Why Preventive Maintenance Costs Less Than the Emergency Call
  • Case Studies Gary Raulino

    Preventative Maintenance – Drain Line Pressure Washing

    Discover how Infinity Group Construction’s preventative drain line pressure washing cut reactive work calls and delivered cost savings for commercial clients.

    Preventative Maintenance – Drain Line Pressure Washing

Canadian-Owned Facility Maintenance, From Coast to Coast.

Since 2003, Infinity Group Construction has kept commercial and retail locations running with self-performed plumbing, electrical, grease interceptor, and equipment maintenance.

NunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonYukonYukonYukonNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonYukonYukonYukonYukonNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonYukonYukonYTYukonYukonNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNUNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonYukonYukonYukonYukonNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNTNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonYukonYukonBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonYukonBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesYukonBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesNorthwest TerritoriesAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecNunavutNunavutNunavutNunavutNorthwest TerritoriesSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecNewfoundland and LabradorNLNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBCBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaABAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQCQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNewfoundland and LabradorNewfoundland and LabradorQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaMBManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSKSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNova ScotiaNova ScotiaNew BrunswickQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNova ScotiaNova ScotiaPrince Edward IslandPENew BrunswickNew BrunswickNew BrunswickQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaAlbertaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaBritish ColumbiaNova ScotiaNSNova ScotiaNew BrunswickNew BrunswickNBQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioONOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanAlbertaAlbertaNova ScotiaNew BrunswickNew BrunswickQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioManitobaManitobaManitobaManitobaSaskatchewanSaskatchewanSaskatchewanNova ScotiaQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecQuebecOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntarioOntario

Same people.
Same standards.
Greater capability.

Infinity Group Construction is Powered by Elevate Service Group

Infinity Group Construction joined Elevate Service Group (TSXV: SERV) in November 2025. We now combine the specialized expertise you rely on with the resources of a national service organization, so you continue to work with the same team you know and trust, backed by a broader platform built to make service simpler.

Elevate Service Group website
  • A broader range of services

    Access to facilities, equipment, and technical solutions beyond electrical

  • Greater coverage and capacity

    Access to Elevate's network of technicians and locations across Canada

  • One trusted partner

    Consolidate multiple services under a single relationship

  • Scale without compromise

    Added resources and support, with the specialized electrical expertise that sets us apart

  • A simpler experience

    Coordinated service, streamlined communication, and less to manage on your end

Let’s talk about your maintenance program. One call covers every location, in every province.

From preventative maintenance to emergency repairs, we’ll build a service plan that keeps every location performing at its best.